Unpacking the Data Center Sustainability Discourse with Building Science

Data centers have become one of the most debated building types in the built environment. In a conversation with Illinois Green Building Alliance’s Matt Watson on the Building Energy Podcast, ZAE’s Dr. Tommy Zakrzewski shared his perspective on everything from building enclosure performance and energy infrastructure to community partnerships and the future of decarbonization.

Here are selected excerpts from that discussion.

What does a building scientist actually do on a hyperscale data center project? And what makes these buildings different from anything else you've modeled and worked on?

Dr. Tommy Zakrzewski: My slice of the pie is to really make sure that the building around the computers and servers and equipment does its job passively. When we're taking a look at the enclosure, we're looking at ways to optimize it so that everything works in sync and perfectly to be the most resilient structure that this building can be. 

Most everyone in the industry – if you're an architect, engineer – you've been designing buildings that are primarily for people. You're designing them in a way that's safe, resilient, and comfortable. But for data centers, you're designing for a different parameter, which is performance of machines and making sure that they run in the way that they're intended to. 

Why does the envelope still matter in a building where the IT load is going to dwarf anything else that we're considering in terms of energy efficiency and use?

Dr. Tommy Z: Everything is turned upon its head when you start looking at a data center. The conditions that are maintained in these facilities – in the electrical rooms, Intermediate Distribution Frame (IDF) rooms, server halls, and all these other ancillary supportive spaces – have completely different set points than many people may be comfortable or familiar with. 

We're trying to avoid the one thing that data centers and electronics absolutely hate, which is moisture and water. Looking at how we adapt current construction technologies and materials into a data center is unique because of the conditions that are held inside. 

Some people may think the envelope isn't very important, but it really is because you're trying to manage the risk and improve the performance on the project. If you don't address it in design, that small insignificant thing could be the thing that breaks an entire project. 

What's the biggest misconception about data centers right now? And where do the critics have legitimate points?

Dr. Tommy Z: There's no typical data center. People may think every one is the same, but it's not. It depends on the equipment, the services, and the climate. All these different aspects change how this data center operates. 

The thing that you hear is data centers are going to take all our water. I love debating that so much because the misinformation that's fed through news channels is just incredible. You charge the system once and it's closed and you're just rejecting heat. It's no different than the radiator on your car. 

With today's type of server technology, you would never use evaporative cooling. It would just make no sense. I could personally say I haven't worked on an evaporative cooling project. It's just not done anymore.

Water's one side of the equation, but energy use is another side. Talk a little bit about that other side and where the criticisms are a little bit more well founded.

Dr. Tommy Z: A lot of energy goes into a data center. We're talking megawatts to gigawatts, from a rack to a building to a campus of buildings that are all doing the same thing, supported by one type of infrastructure, and that's power.  Should people be concerned? Absolutely. The industry – in terms of power generation – hasn't caught up with this demand. 

It's this one moment in the built environment that can completely change our nation's trajectory because it's a moment of infrastructure improvement. If a data center comes in and the local substation needs to be upgraded or high-voltage lines, that makes a community improvement on reliability and delivery.  People need to realize that it's not an enemy. It's this unbelievable partner that you can make with community partnerships, with these hyperscalers and Authority Having Jurisdictions (AHJs), that can make substantial changes. 

Illinois moved to the 2024 IECC and LEED v5 rebuilt its energy category around carbon. What were the biggest debates behind those energy credits and how does that relate to the bigger picture?

Dr. Tommy Z: We're asking a lot out of buildings now in the name of electrification, which is really good because that's the path to decarbonization. Without having that forcing function, your energy codes and your high-performance building standards will never get there. 

How cool would it be to begin to share power between data centers and communities, charging each other's batteries, really doing what a lot of people predicted of how we can exchange data and energy and information between buildings? 

Our codes and energy performance standards are pushing us to be more decarbonized. It's the right time to push in and really accept what's going on and invest in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, decarbonizing, and electrifying everything.

Where do you see data centers headed over the next five years? And what does it look like when, as you put it, they become common as either a Starbucks or a Walgreens?

Dr. Tommy Z: The things that we're seeing in the news that are making the news, the big hyperscale campuses, most likely will taper off. We need something closer to the end user now to interact. 

The localization of data centers is already here, but you're going to see it increase. Bring the data centers closer to where you live and your data center is going to be your new neighbor that's providing you heat. That's where things become interesting, where we're really sharing and utilizing that heat because the data centers want to get rid of it. It's an amazing opportunity. There's so much empty space – including unused office space everywhere – that can pivotally change a building's asset score. It's incredible what it can do to transform communities into more resilient places.

What are you most excited or looking forward to in this sustainable building space, whether it is policies, best practices, or technologies?

Dr. Tommy Z: What I'm most excited about is the conversations that the community and everyone are having. My neighbors, schools, students, politicians, everybody is talking about finding a solution in the built environment. Never in my career have we had this opportunity to make a positive impact collectively. 

If data centers are the enemy, they’re the best enemy we've ever had. It’s substantially changing where the industry is going and our approach to it. That means updating codes and creating mutual benefits for the community.

We'll reflect on this in a couple years and see this as a moment in time that pushed us into an entirely different direction. It's created more jobs and more opportunities, more development and understanding of the impacts of the built environment.

Listen to the full episode here. Want to engage more with a building science expert on these topics? Reach out to Dr. Tommy Z. today.

Next
Next

How Sustainable Building Frameworks Help Address Community Concerns About Data Centers